SaveTheHives/Stories
Honey bee history

The 1957 Brazil bee escape, and the bees that kept coming

A breeding experiment went wrong, 26 colonies got loose, and their descendants walked, so to speak, all the way to Texas. It's also a surprisingly useful story about what happens when honey bees are left to fend for themselves.

By SaveTheHives · Published · Honey bee history · 6 min read

A bee built for the tropics

In the 1950s, Brazilian beekeepers were struggling. The European honey bees brought over centuries earlier were gentle and easy to work with, but they didn't thrive in the tropical climate. The Brazilian government asked geneticist Warwick Estevam Kerr to develop a bee better suited to the conditions.[1]

Kerr looked to Africa, where honey bees were known for strong honey production in warm climates. He also knew they were more defensive than the European bees beekeepers were used to. His plan was to cross the two and end up with a productive bee that was still manageable. He brought African queens back to Brazil (accounts of exactly how many differ) and began breeding.[1]

The escape

In 1957, 26 of the experimental colonies escaped from the breeding apiary near Rio Claro in the state of São Paulo.[1][4] A common version of the story, which traces back to Kerr's own accounts, says a visiting beekeeper removed the queen excluders (the screens that keep queens inside the hive) so the workers could move more freely. The details vary from telling to telling, and some sources simply blame a careless mistake.[1][4]

Whatever the cause, the African queens and their swarms were loose. Kerr reportedly expected them to breed with local European bees and gradually lose their aggressive traits. That's not what happened.

26
colonies escaped in 1957
200–300 mi
spread north each year
1990
first colony found in Texas

Why they spread so fast

The newcomers swarmed more often than European bees, built smaller nests, and stored less honey, so they put more of their energy into reproducing and moving on. With few natural enemies in the Americas, colonies multiplied. They moved north by roughly 200 to 300 miles a year and often took over or interbred with the local bees along the way.[1] Efforts to stop them failed, including a joint U.S.-Mexico barrier zone in southern Mexico that included quarantines, traps, and flooding the area with European drones.[1]

In October 1990 the first Africanized colony in the United States was found near Hidalgo, Texas. The first U.S. death from Africanized bee stings was reported in 1993. Today these bees are established across the southwestern U.S., with a few counties in Louisiana and Arkansas reporting them by 2005.[1]

Where Baton Rouge comes in

Despite what you might have read online, the escape did not happen in Louisiana. But Baton Rouge does have a part in the story. The U.S. Department of Agriculture has run a honey bee research laboratory there since 1928.[2] As Africanized bees moved north, the lab's scientists, led by geneticist Thomas Rinderer, worked on a practical problem: these bees look almost identical to European ones. Their team developed a method for telling them apart by measuring wing size, one of the tools used to track the bees' spread.[1]

The twist beekeepers find interesting

Africanized bees have a second claim to fame. In Brazil they live, largely untreated, in huge numbers, and researchers noticed that Varroa mites (the parasite that devastates European bees in the U.S.) usually seemed to infest them far less. Studies there found very low infestation rates.[3]

Why? Possible explanations include differences in how the bees groom and clean out infested brood, and how well the mites reproduce in their colonies. The tropical climate may also play a role, and scientists have not settled how much of the effect belongs to the bees themselves.[3] What the story does show is that bees left to natural selection, without treatments, can end up with real advantages over managed ones.

That's the idea behind SaveTheHives. Across North America there are non-managed honey bee colonies that have survived winter after winter on their own. Nobody is systematically tracking them. If you know of one, or want to check whether a colony already on our map is still alive, it takes about a minute.
Safety note. Wild nests, especially in parts of the South and Southwest, can be defensive. Observe from a distance, never disturb a nest, and if you want to report one, you can do it from far away. Never approach a colony to log it.

Help find the survivors

Check on a wild colony near you, or report one you've spotted.

Validate a colony

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Where accounts differ, we say so in the article.

  1. Powell, J. & Powell, G. (2021). "Killer Bees Invade the United States." EBSCO Research Starters, History. View source → Supports: Kerr's program, the 1957 escape of 26 colonies, spread rate, the 1990 Texas arrival, the 1993 first U.S. death, Louisiana and Arkansas by 2005, the Bee Regulated Zone, and the wing-measurement identification method.
  2. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. "History at the Lab." Honey Bee Breeding, Genetics, and Physiology Research, Baton Rouge, LA. View source → Supports: the Baton Rouge bee laboratory dating to 1928.
  3. Rosenkranz, P. (1999). "Honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) tolerance to Varroa jacobsoni Oud. in South America." Apidologie 30(2–3): 159–172. doi:10.1051/apido:19990206 View source → Supports: very low Varroa infestation in Brazil’s Africanized bees, and the open question of whether it reflects a host trait or lower mite virulence.
  4. Kerr, W. E. (1969), accounts of the 1957 escape, as summarized in secondary sources (e.g. American Bee Journal, Dec. 2023, "The Bees of Brazil: What Really Happened"). View source → Supports: the Rio Claro location and the queen-excluder story. Told secondhand, and details vary by account.

Cite or share this story