SaveTheHives/Stories
Honey bee research, in plain language

The forest where wild honey bees kept living after the mites arrived

When Varroa mites reached North America, many people assumed wild honey bee colonies would vanish. In one research forest in New York, they did not.

By SaveTheHives · Published · Sources and caveats are listed at the bottom.

A census, then another one

The Arnot Forest is a research preserve of about 1,650 hectares owned by Cornell University in New York State. In 1978, before Varroa mites arrived in North America, scientists counted the wild honey bee colonies living there. In 2002, Thomas Seeley of Cornell counted again. He found as many colonies as before, even though the mites had arrived in the meantime.[1] One account of the work puts the density at roughly 2.5 colonies per square mile in both surveys.[3]

Seeley then followed the colonies he had located. Most of the colonies found in fall 2002 were still alive in fall 2005.[1]

1978 & 2002
two censuses, similar colony numbers
3 years
most 2002 colonies still alive in 2005

The mites were there, but did not run away

The colonies were infested with Varroa. What stood out was that their mite populations did not surge to high levels in late summer.[1]

To test whether the bees were somehow special, Seeley gave mites from a beekeeper's apiary to both Arnot Forest colonies and New World Carniolan colonies (a commercial stock) and compared how fast the mite populations grew. He found no difference. On that basis he concluded in 2007 that the steady relationship might reflect a mite that is less harmful in this setting, rather than bees that resist it.[1] That is one researcher's interpretation of one experiment, and later work has kept the question open.

Are these bees really living on their own?

A fair question is whether the forest colonies are simply swarms escaping from nearby beekeepers, topped up again and again. A 2015 genetic study by Seeley, David Tarpy and colleagues tested this. The forest bees were genetically distinct from bees in two apiaries within 6 kilometers, which suggests the forest population is not being sustained by swarms from those hives. In other words, it appears to be self-sustaining.[2]

They are not an ancient, untouched lineage, though. The authors describe the population as not aboriginal, meaning its ancestors were presumably managed bees that escaped in earlier generations.[2]

So why do they survive?

Nobody has a settled answer. The 2015 authors raised the idea that a closed, naturally living population can settle into a balanced relationship with its diseases and adapt to its local environment. They also noted that living conditions in the wild, such as small nest cavities and frequent swarming, might hold mite numbers down, and that it remains unclear whether host resistance, a less harmful mite, or both are involved.[2]

What this does not show

This is one forest. The genetic comparison used a single year of samples, and the authors mapped only about half of the forest, so the picture is incomplete.[2] The results do not mean wild colonies everywhere will survive without help, and they do not tell beekeepers to stop managing mites. They do show that a non-managed honey bee population can persist with Varroa for years, at least in some places.

Why it matters beyond one forest

If it can happen in the Arnot Forest, it may be happening elsewhere. Most reports of wild colonies are made once and never followed up, so we do not know which ones are still going. Every colony that is confirmed alive year after year is a clue about what helps bees live with mites.

That's where SaveTheHives comes in. Hundreds of wild colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported. Confirming whether one is still alive takes about a minute and gives researchers a place to start.
Safety note. Keep your distance from wild nests and never disturb them. Looking from afar is enough to confirm a colony is still active.

Check on a wild colony

Find one near you and tell us whether it's still there.

Validate a colony

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Where accounts differ, we say so in the article.

  1. Seeley, T. D. (2007). "Honey bees of the Arnot Forest: a population of feral colonies persisting with Varroa destructor in the northeastern United States." Apidologie 38(1): 19–29. doi:10.1051/apido:2006055 View source → Supports: the 1978 and 2002 censuses, survival of most colonies from fall 2002 to fall 2005, mite populations not surging in late summer, the mite-inoculation comparison, and the author's avirulence conclusion. We read the abstract page, not the full paper.
  2. Seeley, T. D., Tarpy, D. R., Griffin, S. R., Carcione, A. & Delaney, D. A. (2015). "A survivor population of wild colonies of European honeybees in the northeastern United States: investigating its genetic structure." Apidologie 46: 654–666. doi:10.1007/s13592-015-0355-0 View source → Supports: genetic distinctness from apiaries within 6 km, the self-sustaining and not-aboriginal conclusions, the possible explanations offered, and the stated limitations (one year of sampling, about half the forest mapped). We reviewed the paper through an automated summary of the publisher's PDF rather than reading it ourselves, so check specifics against the paper.
  3. Seeley, T. D. (2017). "How a population of wild honey bee colonies living in New York State is surviving." American Bee Journal 157(11). View source → Supports: only the approximate density figure (about 2.5 colonies per square mile in both surveys). Magazine article by the researcher; we reviewed it through an automated summary, not a full read.

Cite or share this story