SaveTheHives/Stories
Honey bee mysteries

"Disappearing disease": the bee mystery that came long before colony collapse

In 2006 and 2007 the world learned the phrase "colony collapse disorder." But beekeepers had been watching colonies empty out for well over a century, and one of those episodes had a name of its own.

By SaveTheHives · Published · Honey bee mysteries · 5 min read

Six hundred colonies, almost no bees

In April 1973, a migratory beekeeper in the Rio Grande Valley of Texas reported losing about 600 of his 3,500 colonies. The hives had been busy raising brood earlier in the year. Then the weather turned cold and rainy for about two weeks, and the adult workers declined rapidly to a "handful" of bees and a queen. There were only a few dozen dead bees on the bottom boards or in front of each hive. Weeks of feeding sugar syrup and pollen substitute didn't save them. The beekeeper had more than thirty years of experience.[1][2]

That account comes from a 1979 paper in American Bee Journal by W. T. Wilson and D. M. Menapace. They reviewed the older literature and found that this kind of unexplained loss, which they called "disappearing disease," went back at least to the 1800s.[1][2] Beekeepers also used terms like "spring dwindling" for colonies that shrank during cold snaps. Nobody could explain it.[1]

It came back, and still wasn't solved

In the early 1980s, Ohio State University researchers J. M. Kulincevic, W. C. Rothenbuhler, and Thomas Rinderer revisited the problem in a research bulletin that compared seven different stocks of honey bees.[3] Once again, the best minds available couldn't pin down a cause. And then, as before, the disease seemed to fade away on its own.[1]

1800s
earliest reports of similar losses
1973
Texas losses described in 1979 paper
~2007
“colony collapse disorder” enters the headlines

What does "disappearing" actually mean?

Beekeeper and researcher Randy Oliver made a point in a 2008 article that's easy to miss: the bees probably aren't vanishing into thin air. They're failing to come back. A colony's size is a balance between new bees hatching and old foragers dying. Forager bees have a hard life and wear out their wings, and a healthy forager might last two weeks or more. In a population-model run Oliver shared, a colony whose foragers lasted 16 days grew strong, while one whose foragers lasted only 4 days never built up, even though it still looked healthy from the outside.[1]

In other words, anything that shortens a forager's life, such as cold, poor nutrition, disease, or pesticide exposure, can quietly drain a colony. Later research also suggests that sick bees may leave the hive on purpose, a behavior sometimes called "altruistic self-removal."[1]

Is it the same thing as colony collapse?

Some beekeepers and researchers noticed the resemblance when large losses hit in the mid-2000s. Whether disappearing disease and colony collapse disorder are the same phenomenon was never settled, and scientists generally describe modern collapses as having several contributing factors rather than a single cause.[1]

What wild colonies could tell us

Every one of these episodes was noticed because beekeepers were watching managed colonies closely. We know very little about how non-managed colonies, the ones living in tree hollows and old buildings with no help, fared during these same stretches. Did they dwindle? Did they hold steady? Nobody was tracking.

That's a gap SaveTheHives wants to close. Each time someone confirms a wild colony is still alive, it becomes a data point researchers can use. A single check-in takes about a minute.

Check on a wild colony

Hundreds of colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported.

Validate a colony

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Where accounts differ, we say so in the article.

  1. Oliver, R. (2008). "Old Bees / Cold Bees / No Bees? Part 1." American Bee Journal, June 2008; updated 2011. ScientificBeekeeping.com. View source → Supports: the 1973 Texas account, the long history of unexplained losses, the forager-lifespan explanation, the 16-day vs. 4-day population model, and “altruistic self-removal.”
  2. Wilson, W. T. & Menapace, D. M. (1979). On "disappearing disease." American Bee Journal. Quoted and discussed in Oliver (2008), source [1]. Supports: the 1973 Rio Grande Valley losses and the review of earlier reports back to the 1800s. We have not read the original paper; this is as quoted in [1].
  3. Kulincevic, J. M., Rothenbuhler, W. C. & Rinderer, T. E. (1984). "Disappearing disease: III. A comparison of seven different stocks of the honey bee (Apis mellifera)." Ohio State University Research Bulletin 1160. As listed in the references of Oliver (2008), source [1]. Supports: the early-1980s study that compared seven honey bee stocks. We have not read the original bulletin.

Cite or share this story