SaveTheHives/Stories
Search question

Do wild honey bees still exist in North America?

Honey bees aren't native to North America, but colonies living on their own in tree cavities and buildings have been here for centuries. Then the Varroa mite arrived. Did they survive?

By SaveTheHives · Published · 4 min read

Safety first. Keep your distance from wild nests. Don't poke, knock, spray, or block the entrance, and keep children and pets back.

Short answer: yes, in places we have looked

A 2020 study of wild and managed honey bees in southwestern Pennsylvania opens with the background: wild colonies in the USA declined sharply after the Varroa mite arrived in the 1980s, but some survived.[3] That "some survived" is the part scientists have been able to document, but only in a few places.

The best-studied population: Arnot Forest, New York

Cornell's Thomas Seeley censused non-managed colonies in the Arnot Forest, a 1,651-hectare research preserve, in 1978, before Varroa reached North America. He repeated the census in 2002 and found as many colonies as in 1978. Most colonies located in fall 2002 were still alive in fall 2005.[1]

That is not the whole story. A later genetic study of preserved specimens collected in 1977 and 2010 found that Varroa killed most of the wild colonies in the forest, which caused a genetic bottleneck, and that the population then rebounded. Maternal-line DNA lost a lot of diversity, while nuclear DNA stayed diverse and showed signs of adaptation.[2] In other words, the colonies you can find there today are survivors of a hard crash, not an unbroken line.

Are they just escaped beekeeper bees?

It is a fair question, and the sources are careful about it. The Cornell Chronicle's summary of the genetics study says the data showed little gene flow from outside populations such as managed bees, but also notes that the 2002 rebound could reflect either repopulation from beekeepers' hives or strong natural selection, and the study does not settle which.[2] A separate 2015 analysis of queens in the same forest found the non-managed colonies were genetically distinct from bees in the two nearest apiaries, and that few new alleles from the nearest apiary showed up in the forest population.[4]

Another region: southwestern Pennsylvania

Over three years, researchers examined 32 wild colonies and 11 managed colonies in southwestern Pennsylvania. The wild colonies carried nine maternal-lineage (mtDNA) haplotypes, six from the Eastern European lineage and three from the Western European lineage. The managed colonies had only three, all Eastern European. The authors conclude that wild colonies can preserve old lineages. They also found that wild and managed colonies had similar levels of the gut pathogens Nosema ceranae and N. apis, so these bees are not invulnerable.[3]

What nobody knows yet

These are two regions. We did not find a national count of non-managed honey bee colonies, and the Arnot Forest is a protected research preserve, so its results may not apply everywhere. The Cornell summary also stresses that the genes and traits behind survival have not been identified.[2] And what happens in a typical backyard, barn, or woodlot in your state is mostly unrecorded.

Where SaveTheHives fits

That gap is exactly what a map can help fill. Each reported colony, and each later check that it is still active, is a small data point about where non-managed colonies are living and how long they last.

Add or check on a wild colony

Hundreds of colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported.

Add a colony   Validate one

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. We read abstracts and publisher pages, not every full paper; each source is labeled below.

  1. Seeley, T. D. (2007). "Honey bees of the Arnot Forest: a population of feral colonies persisting with Varroa destructor in the northeastern United States." Apidologie 38(1): 19–29. doi:10.1051/apido:2006055. View source → Supports: 1,651-ha preserve, 1978 census, 2002 census with as many colonies as 1978, most 2002 colonies alive in 2005. Abstract and publisher page read; full paper not read.
  2. Ramanujan, K. "Some honeybee colonies adapt in wake of deadly mites." Cornell Chronicle, August 7, 2015 (on Mikheyev et al., Nature Communications, 2015). View source → Supports: 1977 and 2010 specimens, most colonies killed then rebound, mtDNA diversity loss with nuclear diversity retained, little outside gene flow, unresolved repopulation vs. selection, traits not yet identified. SECONDHAND news coverage; the Nature Communications paper itself was not read.
  3. Rangel, J., Traver, B., Stoner, M., Hatter, A., Trevelline, B., Garza, C., Shepherd, T., Seeley, T. D., Wenzel, J., et al. (2020). "Genetic diversity of wild and managed honey bees (Apis mellifera) in Southwestern Pennsylvania, and prevalence of the microsporidian gut pathogens Nosema ceranae and N. apis." Apidologie 51(5): 802–814. doi:10.1007/s13592-020-00762-5. View source → Supports: sharp decline after Varroa in the 1980s with some survivors, 32 wild vs. 11 managed colonies, haplotype counts, Nosema comparison. Abstract only; author list truncated on the page we read.
  4. Tarpy, D. R., Delaney, D. A., & Seeley, T. D. (2015). "Mating frequencies of honey bee queens (Apis mellifera L.) in a population of feral colonies in the northeastern United States." PLoS ONE 10(3): e0118734. View source → Supports: Arnot colonies genetically distinct from the two nearest apiaries; few novel alleles from the nearest apiary. Read via a page summary of the open-access paper; some managed input is possible per the authors.

Cite or share this story