SaveTheHives/Stories
Honey bee research, in plain language

The Swedish island where untreated honey bees learned to live with mites

Most beekeepers would never dare to leave their bees untreated against Varroa mites. Swedish researchers did it on purpose, on an island, and then watched for years to see who would survive.

By SaveTheHives · Published · Honey bee research · 5 min read

An experiment on an island

Varroa mites are the parasite most responsible for honey bee colony losses worldwide. Managed colonies are usually protected with regular treatments. To find out what happens without them, researchers established an isolated population of 150 colonies on the southern tip of Gotland, an island in the Baltic Sea. They deliberately infested each colony with between 36 and 89 mites, then left the bees alone. The colonies were left unmanaged and free to swarm.[1]

Heavy losses first, then a turnaround

The early years were hard. Winter death rates in the third and fourth years were 76% and 57%. Then something shifted. In the fifth and sixth years, winter mortality fell to 13% and 19%. Swarming, which is how a wild colony reproduces, rose from zero in the third season to 57% and 36% in the last two years. And mites on adult bees became less common, falling from 0.47% in year three to about 0.2% in each of the last two years.[1]

The researchers concluded that the bees and the mites appeared to have reached a kind of truce, with both host and parasite surviving, and said the mechanisms behind it needed further study.[1]

76%
winter losses in year 3
13%
winter losses in year 5
10+ yrs
untreated survival reported by 2011

What was different about the survivors?

A follow-up study by Barbara Locke and Ingemar Fries looked at the Gotland population after more than ten years of surviving without treatment. The result surprised many people. The survivors were not better at the behaviors beekeepers often hope for: their rates of removing infested brood and of grooming mites off adult bees were not significantly different from treated comparison colonies.[2]

What did differ was that the surviving colonies were smaller, and the mites reproduced less successfully inside them. The authors suggested that traits at the level of the whole colony may limit how fast the mite population can grow.[2]

What this does not show

It's worth being careful here. Gotland is an island with a cold climate, and this was a research population set up by scientists, not a group of colonies found living on their own. The early losses were severe. The results don't mean that any wild colony will survive without help, or that the same mechanisms explain every survivor population elsewhere. They do show that, given time and natural selection, honey bees and mites can settle into a more balanced relationship.

Why it matters on the mainland

Gotland was a deliberate experiment. On the mainland, nature has been running similar experiments quietly for years. Researchers have, for example, studied a population of feral colonies persisting with Varroa in the Arnot Forest of New York.[3] Every non-managed colony that survives winter after winter without treatment is a candidate for the same kind of question: what is it doing differently? The trouble is that most were found once and never checked again.

That's where SaveTheHives comes in. Hundreds of wild colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported. Confirming whether one is still alive takes about a minute and gives researchers a place to start.
Safety note. Observe wild colonies from a distance and never disturb a nest.

Check on a wild colony

Find one near you and tell us whether it's still there.

Validate a colony

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Where accounts differ, we say so in the article.

  1. Fries, I., Imdorf, A. & Rosenkranz, P. (2006). "Survival of mite infested (Varroa destructor) honey bee (Apis mellifera) colonies in a Nordic climate." Apidologie 37(5): 564–570. doi:10.1051/apido:2006031 View source → Supports: the Gotland setup (150 colonies, 36 to 89 mites each, unmanaged), the winter mortality and swarming figures, the fall in mite infestation, and the authors' co-adaptation conclusion. We read the abstract, not the full paper.
  2. Locke, B. & Fries, I. (2011). "Characteristics of honey bee colonies (Apis mellifera) in Sweden surviving Varroa destructor infestation." Apidologie 42(4): 533–542. View abstract → Supports: more than ten years of untreated survival, similar brood removal and grooming compared with treated colonies, and smaller colonies with reduced mite reproductive success. We read the abstract (as reproduced on the Pestinfo wiki), not the full paper.
  3. "Honey bees of the Arnot Forest: a population of feral colonies persisting with Varroa destructor in the northeastern United States." Apidologie 38: 19–29 (2007). View source → Supports: that the Arnot Forest population has been studied. We have seen only the title, not the paper, and make no further claim about its findings.

Cite or share this story