A swarm hanging from a branch looks like a bee cloud with no plan. Researchers who studied swarms found a house-hunting process that is organized, competitive, and surprisingly picky.
A swarm forms in early summer when a colony becomes overcrowded. About two-thirds of the worker bees and the old queen leave and gather on a nearby branch, while the search for a permanent home begins.[2] The cluster you see hanging in a tree is a waiting room. A few hundred of the oldest bees, the scouts, fan out to look for a hollow to move into.[2]
Scouts typically find 10 to 20 candidate sites, often hollow trees, and judge them on factors such as cavity volume and entrance size.[2] A review by Cornell's Thomas Seeley and P. Kirk Visscher summarizes experiments showing that scouts favor cavities larger than about 10 liters with a small entrance, under 30 square centimeters.[1] The same review reports that scouts judge a cavity's size partly by how much interior surface they have to walk, and that the shape of the cavity and of its entrance do not seem to matter.[1]
A scout that finds a good site returns to the swarm and advertises it with a waggle dance, which signals the direction and distance of the site. In the experiments described in the review, a scout danced more vigorously for a better site, with an average of 36 waggle runs per dance for an excellent box versus 14 for mediocre ones.[1] Other scouts follow dances, go inspect that site, and then dance for it themselves if they agree. The site that recruits the most scouts grows its lead.[1] A scout inspects a site herself before dancing for it, so enthusiasm cannot simply be copied from another bee.[1]
Seeley and Visscher tested this by placing one excellent 40-liter nest box and four mediocre 15-liter boxes about 230 to 250 meters from a swarm of roughly 4,000 bees. In their experiments, four of five swarms chose the best box.[1] That is a small number of swarms, so it is better read as a striking result than as a law of nature, and the authors themselves describe how some of the underlying mechanisms are still open questions.[1]
The swarm does not wait for every scout to agree. The review describes the decision as reaching a quorum: when roughly 10 to 15 or more scouts are present at one site, they begin to rouse the resting swarm and prepare it to fly. Exactly how scouts sense that the threshold has been reached is among the questions the review treats as unresolved.[1] In one example the process took about 16 hours of dancing spread over three days.[1]
The result of all this house-hunting is a wild colony in a tree hollow or other cavity, the kind of nest SaveTheHives volunteers report. What happens to these colonies afterward, and how long each one lasts, is far less studied than how they choose a home. Every confirmed nest, and every later check that it is still active, adds to what is known.
Hundreds of colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported.
One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.
Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Neither was read in print; we have not independently verified claims beyond what these sources state.