SaveTheHives/Stories
Honey bee research, in plain language

Why Brazil's honey bees live with Varroa mites, and what nobody can yet explain

In much of the world, Varroa mites are the biggest threat to honey bees. In Brazil, the mite has been present for more than four decades, bees are largely left untreated, and mite numbers have stayed low. Scientists have three suspects and no verdict.

By SaveTheHives · Published · Honey bee research · 5 min read

A mite arrives, and the usual disaster doesn't follow

Varroa mites reached Brazil in 1979. Chemical mite treatments are not registered for use there, and treating colonies is generally not practised.[1] In many other countries that would be a recipe for collapse. Yet in the Africanized honey bees that dominate Brazil, adult-bee infestation has mostly stayed below 5%.[1] (For readers new to the story: Africanized bees are the descendants of African bees that escaped a breeding program in 1957. That history is here.)

One study in southern Brazil measured the same apiary, with no treatments, five years apart and found infestation had barely moved. It averaged about two mites per hundred adult bees, with roughly 5% of brood cells infested.[2]

1979
Varroa arrives in Brazil
<5%
typical mite infestation of adult bees
~2 per 100
mites per 100 adult bees in one southern Brazil apiary

Suspect one: the bees

Researchers have found several differences in how Africanized bees handle the mite.

Mites reproduce less. A female mite enters a brood cell, lays eggs, and her young feed on the developing bee. In Brazilian studies of Africanized worker brood, only about half of the mites that entered a cell laid eggs, with the share ranging from 37% to 57%. At one site, about 80% of mites reproduced in the worker brood of European-lineage bees, a significantly higher share.[1] Mites in drone brood still reproduced about 90% of the time, so the effect is specific to worker brood.[1]

More grooming. In observation-hive tests, Africanized bees removed 38% of mites from adult bees, compared with 5% for a European subspecies.[1] That said, some Africanized colonies with weak grooming still had low infestations, so grooming alone does not explain it.[1]

Opening infested cells. In a later experiment, highly hygienic Africanized colonies uncapped about 1.7% of sealed brood cells per day on combs naturally infested with mites, compared with 0.5% on uninfested combs. The authors concluded the bees must have some way of detecting mites inside sealed cells, and suggested this may help explain tolerance, though they did not measure its effect on mite populations.[3]

Suspect two: the mite

Mites reproduce fast, so they can evolve fast. Some researchers have raised the possibility that the mites in Brazil are simply less harmful than mites elsewhere. The mites in Brazil trace to a Japanese source, but the mites in Argentina and Uruguay, where bees fared worse, had not been analysed for comparison at the time of the review we relied on.[1]

Suspect three: the climate

Where the weather is warm, bees can raise brood nearly year-round, and the way mites and bees interact changes. In a 1986 to 1988 study cited in the review, adult infestation above 10% showed up only in a cold mountain area of Santa Catarina during periods with little brood.[1] In non-tropical Argentina, colonies could not survive without treatment.[1]

A hint that it isn't only the bees

In 1984, twenty colonies of European honey bees (A. m. ligustica) carrying Varroa were placed on an isolated island off northeastern Brazil that had no honey bees. They have survived without treatment and multiplied by swarming.[1] The review's author took this as a sign that European bees can also become tolerant under tropical conditions.[1]

What this does not show

The honest summary is that nobody has settled it. The review concluded that its data cannot show whether the tolerance is a trait of the bees or results from a less harmful mite.[1] Climate may matter too. The research we cite is also mostly from the 1990s and 2000s, and we have not tried to survey everything published since. Brazil's results do not mean untreated bees will do well in every region, and the early studies' older mite name (Varroa jacobsoni) refers to the mite now generally called Varroa destructor in the later Brazilian papers.

Why it matters here

Brazil, Gotland, and the Arnot Forest in New York each suggest that honey bees left alone can reach an uneasy peace with Varroa, through different routes. Colonies living on their own in the United States may be running similar experiments right now. The difficulty is that most were reported once and never checked again.

That's the gap SaveTheHives wants to close. Confirming whether a reported wild colony is still alive takes about a minute and tells researchers where to look. Please observe from a distance and never disturb a wild nest.

Check on a wild colony

Hundreds of colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported.

Validate a colony

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Where accounts differ, we say so in the article.

  1. Rosenkranz, P. (1999). "Honey bee (Apis mellifera L.) tolerance to Varroa jacobsoni Oud. in South America." Apidologie 30(2–3): 159–172. doi:10.1051/apido:19990206 View source → Supports: 1979 arrival; no registered treatments; infestation mostly below 5%; 37–57% of mites reproducing in worker brood vs. about 80% in European bees, and about 90% in drone brood; grooming 38% vs. 5%; the cold-area infestation above 10%; Argentina needing treatment; the 1984 island colonies; the mite-origin discussion; and the conclusion that host trait vs. mite virulence cannot be separated. This is a review of other people’s studies, so the specific numbers are as reported there. We read the full text through an automated summary, not line by line.
  2. Moretto, G. & Leonidas, J. de M. (2003). "Infestation and distribution of the mite Varroa destructor in colonies of Africanized bees." Brazilian Journal of Biology 63(1). View source → Supports: about two mites per 100 adult bees (adult 2.33%, brood 5.06%) and an apiary that showed essentially no change from five years earlier (1.78% in 1995) with no treatments. We read the abstract page, not the full paper.
  3. Moretto, G., Guerra Jr., J. C. V. & Bittencourt, C. V. (2006). "Uncapping activity of Apis mellifera L. (Hymenoptera: Apidae) towards worker brood cells infested with the mite Varroa destructor Anderson & Trueman (Mesostigmata: Varroidae)." Neotropical Entomology 35(3): 299–301. View source → Supports: 1.7% vs. 0.5% daily uncapping, the authors’ conclusion that bees detect mites in sealed cells, and their caution that only highly hygienic colonies were tested and population effects were not measured. We read the abstract page, not the full paper.

Cite or share this story