SaveTheHives/Stories
From the archives

"An Idyl of the Honey-Bee": how a naturalist hunted wild bees in 1881

Long before anyone mapped wild colonies, John Burroughs followed bees through the New York hills to find where they lived. Some of what he wrote holds up, some does not, and one skill he describes is still used today.

By SaveTheHives · Published · From the archives · 5 min read

Safety first. Burroughs cut open trees and smoked out bees. Please don't. Watch wild nests from a distance and never poke, spray, or block an entrance.

John Burroughs was an American naturalist and essayist. His essay "An Idyl of the Honey-Bee," collected in his 1881 book Pepacton, is an account of an autumn day spent bee-hunting: tracking wild honey bees back to the trees where they nest.[1] It is an essay, not a study, so we read it as a historical eyewitness account and not as data. Here are four of its passages, and what we know now.

1. "Essentially a wild creature"

"Yet the fact remains that the honey-bee is essentially a wild creature, and never has been and cannot be thoroughly domesticated. Its proper home is the woods, and thither every new swarm counts on going; …"[1]

Then and now. Burroughs was describing the hills within sight of the Catskills, where he found bee trees. Researchers have since counted wild colonies in a New York research forest: Cornell biologist Thomas Seeley found about as many colonies there in 2002 as in 1978, and most of the colonies he followed from 2002 to 2005 survived.[3] That is one forest, not a continental count, and we tell it in more detail in The forest where wild honey bees kept living after the mites arrived.

2. Chimneys, barns, and knot-holes

"If the woods in any given locality are deficient in trees with suitable cavities the bees resort to all sorts of makeshifts; they go into chimneys, into barns and outhouses, under stones, into rocks, and so forth."[1]

Then and now. That list could be a description of our map. Of the 1,140 colonies reported to SaveTheHives so far, 426 are in man-made structures and 373 are in living trees, with smaller numbers in man-made hives, dead trees, and the ground.[5] Experiments reviewed by Seeley and P. Kirk Visscher found that house-hunting scouts favor cavities larger than about 10 liters with a small entrance.[2] We explain that in How a swarm of bees picks a new home.

3. Two lines and a triangle

"The two lines we have established form two sides of a triangle of which the wall is the base; at the apex of the triangle, or where the two lines meet in the woods, we are sure to find the tree."[1]

Then and now. Burroughs baited a box with honey, watched where the bees flew, then moved the box and watched again. He called it "cross-lining," and it is the same idea as the beelining taught in our Learn tab. Seeley's 2016 book Following the Wild Bees describes bee hunting as a craft and a science, covering the bee box, establishing a beeline, timing the bees to estimate distance, and finding the tree.[4]

One thing he got wrong. Burroughs wrote, "I suspect the bee does not tell its fellows what it has found, but that they smell out the secret; …"[1] Researchers have since documented that bees do communicate with the waggle dance. For example, the review by Seeley and Visscher describes scouts advertising a nest site to the swarm by dancing.[2]

4. The old hemlock stump

"The bees have been here many years, and have of course sent out swarm after swarm into the wilds."[1]

Then and now. This is the most useful sentence for us, and also the least provable. Burroughs found a colony in an old hemlock stump that gave about fifty pounds of honey, and he wrote that the bees had been there "many years." He does not say how he knew, and no one could have counted the winters. That is exactly the gap SaveTheHives is trying to fill: a colony confirmed year after year builds a record that a single observer's guess cannot.

Why an old essay matters

Burroughs ends with a line that still holds: wild honey is "flavored with your adventure." Nearly a century and a half later, the adventure he describes is open to anyone willing to watch quietly. If you can find a wild colony, or check on one already on the map, you are doing a version of what he did.

Check on a wild colony

Hundreds of colonies on our map haven't been checked since they were first reported.

Validate a colony

New stories by email, about weekly

One short email when each new story goes out: surprising wild honey bee history and science.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources & citations

Numbers in brackets in the text above point to these sources. Where accounts differ, we say so in the article.

  1. Burroughs, J. (1881). "An Idyl of the Honey-Bee." In Pepacton: A Summer Voyage, and Other Essays. Houghton, Mifflin and Company, The Riverside Press, Cambridge, 1890 printing (copyright 1881), pp. 65–89 (the "wild creature" and chimney passages are on p. 66, the triangle passage on p. 76, and the hemlock stump passage on p. 81). Read it on Project Gutenberg → Supports: the quotations in sections 1 through 4, each checked against a printed 1890 copy (pp. 66, 66, 76, and 81; the dance remark is on p. 74), and the closing line. The remark in section 3 about bees telling each other what they find is on p. 74. The essay is in the public domain. The Gutenberg edition is a later collected-works printing of Pepacton.
  2. Seeley, T. D. & Visscher, P. K. (2004). "Group decision making in nest-site selection by honey bees." Apidologie 35(2): 101–116. DOI 10.1051/apido:2004004. View source → Supports: scouts favor cavities over about 10 liters with a small entrance, and scouts advertise nest sites to the swarm by waggle dance. Only the abstract was read on the publisher page; some details come from a third-party full-text copy read through an automated summary.
  3. Seeley, T. D. (2007). "Honey bees of the Arnot Forest: a population of feral colonies persisting with Varroa destructor in the northeastern United States." Apidologie 38(1): 19–29. doi:10.1051/apido:2006055 View source → Supports: the 1978 and 2002 censuses and survival of most tracked colonies from 2002 to 2005. We read the abstract page, not the full paper.
  4. Seeley, T. D. (2016). Following the Wild Bees: The Craft and Science of Bee Hunting. Princeton University Press. Excerpt and coverage (Harvard Magazine) → Supports: only that the book exists and covers bee hunting as a craft and science, including establishing a beeline, timing bees to estimate distance, and finding the tree. We have not read the book; we relied on library catalog, review, and excerpt pages.
  5. SaveTheHives colony records, accessed November 9, 2026 (1,140 reported colonies, all years). Supports: 426 colonies reported in man-made structures, 373 in living trees, 270 in man-made beehives, 41 in dead trees, and 30 in the ground. These are citizen reports; most have never been confirmed.

Cite or share this story